Analyze feasibility of migrating from Django to Laravel; recommend maintaining current implementation due to high risks and costs

This commit is contained in:
pacnpal
2025-02-18 10:43:13 -05:00
parent 0b51ee123a
commit 78f465b273
2 changed files with 284 additions and 21 deletions

View File

@@ -1,28 +1,37 @@
# Active Context - Park View Modularization
# Active Context - Laravel Migration Analysis
**Objective:** Refactor parks view to use reusable card component and implement grid/list view toggle
**Objective:** Evaluate feasibility and impact of migrating from Django to Laravel
**Current Implementation Analysis:**
- Park cards rendered via `park_list_item.html` partial
- Existing layout uses flex-based list structure
- Search functionality uses HTMX for dynamic updates
**Key Decision:** ⛔️ Do NOT proceed with Laravel migration (see detailed analysis in `decisions/laravel_migration_analysis.md`)
**Planned Changes:**
1. **Create `park_card.html` Partial**
- Extract card markup from `park_list_item.html`
- Add responsive grid/list view classes
- Include view mode toggle state
**Analysis Summary:**
1. **High Technical Risk**
- Complex custom Django features
- Extensive model relationships
- Specialized history tracking system
- Geographic/location services integration
2. **View Toggle Implementation**
- Add grid/list toggle UI with HTMX
- Store view preference in cookie/localStorage
- Update CSS for grid (grid-cols) vs list (flex) layouts
2. **Significant Business Impact**
- Estimated 4-6 month timeline
- $180,000-230,000 direct costs
- Service disruption risks
- Resource-intensive implementation
3. **Backend Updates**
- Add view_mode parameter to park list view
- Modify context processor to handle layout preference
3. **Critical Systems Affected**
- Authentication and permissions
- Data model architecture
- Template system and HTMX integration
- API and service layers
**Recommended Direction:**
1. Maintain and enhance current Django implementation
2. Focus on feature development and optimization
3. Consider hybrid approach for new features if needed
**Next Steps:**
- Implement card partial with responsive classes
- Create view toggle component
- Update HTMX handlers to preserve view mode
1. Document current system architecture thoroughly
2. Identify optimization opportunities
3. Update dependencies and security
4. Enhance development workflows
**Previous Context:** Park View Modularization work can continue as planned - the decision to maintain Django architecture means we can proceed with planned UI improvements.